Portable vs. Standby Generators: A Homeowner's Buyer's Guide
Power goes out in Western PA — ice storms, summer storms, the occasional car-meets-pole. Here's how to pick the right generator, size it correctly, and get it wired safely, from an electrician who installs them.
Jason Mohoska · Owner-Operator, JS Power LLC
Licensed Pennsylvania Home Improvement Contractor · PA HIC #PA166735
Serving Pittsburgh & Western Pennsylvania
Section 1
The three types: portable, inverter, standby
Portable generators are the familiar gas-powered units on wheels. You roll them outside, run extension cords, or plug into a professionally installed inlet. They power essentials — fridge, sump pump, a few lights — and cost the least up front. Downsides: they're loud, they burn through fuel, and someone has to be home to set them up in the storm.
Inverter generators are the quieter, more fuel-efficient cousins. They produce cleaner power (safe for electronics and computers), sip fuel, and run much quieter — great for tailgating, RVs, and running a few essentials during shorter outages. They cost more per watt than conventional portables and top out at lower power levels.
Standby (whole-house) generators are permanently installed outside your home, wired into your panel through an automatic transfer switch, and start themselves within seconds of an outage — whether you're home or not. They run on natural gas or propane, so no refueling in a storm. They're the set-it-and-forget-it option, and the most expensive one.
⛔ Carbon monoxide kills
Never run any fuel-burning generator indoors, in a garage (even with the door open), or near windows and doors. CO is odorless and deadly. Place portables at least 20 feet from the house, exhaust pointed away.
Section 2
How much power do you actually need?
Generators are rated in watts, and there are two numbers that matter: running watts (what it can sustain) and starting watts (the brief surge to start motors — a fridge or sump pump can need 2–3× its running watts to kick on).
The right way to size: list what you must keep running. Typical essentials:
Refrigerator/freezer: ~150–800 running watts (1,200+ to start)
Sump pump: ~800–1,000 running watts (2,000+ to start)
Furnace blower (gas heat): ~500–1,200 watts
Well pump: ~1,000–2,000 running watts (3,000+ to start)
Lights, phone chargers, WiFi: a few hundred watts total
Add up the running watts of everything you'd run at once, add the largest starting surge on top, and add 20% headroom. Most homes' essentials land in the 5,000–8,000 watt range — which is why 7,500W portables are so popular. Trying to run central AC, electric range, and dryer on a portable is how people buy twice.
Section 3
Transfer switch vs. interlock kit
Here's the part that legally requires an electrician. To feed generator power into your home's circuits (instead of running extension cords everywhere), you need one of two devices:
Manual transfer switch: a separate panel wired next to your main panel. During an outage you flip selected circuits from utility to generator power. Clean, clearly labeled, and the safest option for portables. Installed cost is typically a few hundred dollars plus the electrician's labor.
Interlock kit: a mechanical sliding plate on your existing panel that makes it physically impossible for the main breaker and the generator breaker to be on at the same time. Cheaper than a transfer switch and lets you power any circuit in the panel (up to the generator's capacity). Must be a listed kit made for your specific panel — not a homemade workaround.
⛔ Never backfeed
Plugging a generator into a wall outlet ("backfeeding") energizes the utility lines outside your home and can kill a lineworker trying to restore power. It's illegal, and it's how houses burn down. A transfer switch or listed interlock is the only legal way to connect a generator to your panel.
Section 4
Fuel types: gas, propane, natural gas, dual-fuel
Gasoline: available everywhere, but it goes stale in months, and gas stations lose power in big outages too. Store with stabilizer, rotate your stock.
Propane: stores indefinitely, burns cleaner, and big tanks mean long runtimes. But propane has less energy per gallon, and you'll need tank storage space.
Natural gas: unlimited runtime as long as the gas flows (it usually does during electric outages), zero refueling. Only practical for permanently installed standby units.
Dual-fuel: runs on gasoline or propane — flexibility when one fuel is hard to get. A smart hedge in storm season.
Rule of thumb: if you want "start it and forget it," that's natural gas or propane on a standby unit. If you want affordable backup you manage yourself, that's a dual-fuel portable.
Section 5
What professional installation involves
For a portable with a transfer switch or interlock, installation means: mounting an outdoor power inlet box, wiring it to the transfer switch or interlock breaker, labeling every backed-up circuit, and testing the whole setup under load. Typically a half-day to a full day of work.
For a standby unit, it's a bigger project: concrete or composite pad, gas line run by a plumber or gas fitter, electrical connection through an automatic transfer switch, permits, and inspections. Most standby installs take 1–3 days of coordinated trades.
⚠ Permits and inspections
Most municipalities require a permit for generator connections to a home's electrical system, and standby units almost always do. An unpermitted install can void your homeowner's insurance when you need it most.
Section 6
Maintenance: the part everyone skips
A generator that won't start in a storm is an expensive paperweight. The maintenance list is short but non-negotiable:
Run it monthly for 10–15 minutes under load — this is the single most important habit.
Change the oil per the manual (usually every 50–100 hours of runtime, or yearly).
Fresh fuel: stabilize gasoline, or run the carburetor dry before storage.
Battery: standby units have a starter battery — check it yearly, replace every 2–3 years.
Exercise mode: most standby units self-test weekly — make sure it's actually enabled.
Section 7
What it costs (national ballparks)
These are national ballpark ranges, not quotes — local labor, permits, and your panel's condition move the numbers:
Portable generator (7,500W class): roughly $800–$1,500 for the unit
Inverter generator: roughly $1,000–$2,500 depending on size
Transfer switch or interlock + inlet, professionally installed: roughly $500–$1,500
Standby unit (whole-house): roughly $5,000–$12,000+ installed, depending on size and gas work
The honest math: a portable plus a proper transfer-switch install often lands under $2,500 all-in and covers the essentials. A standby costs 3–5× more and covers everything, automatically, whether you're home or not.
Thinking about a generator? Call JS Power LLC for a generator install assessment — we'll size it right, wire the transfer switch or interlock to code, and make sure it actually starts when the storm hits.
Jason answers directly · Licensed PA HIC #PA166735
About the author
Need an electrician? Call JS Power LLC.
I'm Jason Mohoska, owner-operator of JS Power LLC — a licensed electrical contractor serving Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania. 20+ years in the trade. When you call, you deal directly with me: I quote the job, I do the work, and it passes inspection.
Licensed Pennsylvania Home Improvement Contractor · PA HIC #PA166735
20% off for veterans (DOD ID required) & senior citizensNew-Age Electrical Products
Hard-to-find smart & LED gear — supplied & installed.
Most stores don't carry the good stuff — or they sell it without anyone to install it right. I source new-age electrical products (smart switches, dimmers, LED retrofits) and install them to code. One call, one flat price, working before I leave. Have a specific device in mind? Ask — if it's legit and listed, I'll get it.
3 Kasa HS220 WiFi dimmers, supplied & installed, scenes & schedules set up
Smart Home Starter Kit
$149
4 smart plugs + 4 color bulbs, delivered & connected to your WiFi
LED Retrofit 6-Pack
$549
6 recessed LED retrofits, supplied & installed, dimmable
New Recessed Room Pack
$899
4 new wafer lights for one room, supplied & installed
LED Security Duo
$349
2 dusk-to-dawn LED security lights, supplied & installed
Custom LED Sign
from $499
Your name, logo or artwork built as LED neon & installed — man caves, bars, businesses
Unique imports — global smart tech, hard to find in US stores
Innovative gear from established overseas makers (Aqara, Govee, SwitchBot, Lumary, Treatlife, Sonoff) — I only install UL- or ETL-listed devices, no exceptions, installed to code. Ordered new-in-box for your job.
Smart Recessed 4-Pack
$949
4 Lumary color-tunable smart canless downlights, supplied & installed, app + voice set up
Smart Switch Swap 4-Pack
$399
4 Treatlife WiFi switches with flush snap-on plates, supplied & installed, no hub needed
Energy Hog Hunt
$99
4 Sonoff energy-monitoring smart plugs, set up with a usage review to find your power hogs
No-Rewire Retrofit Kit
$149
SwitchBot button-pressers + hub — makes dumb switches smart with zero wiring, mounted & connected
Presence Automation
$199
Aqara FP2 mmWave presence sensor — lights that know you're still in the room, mounted & integrated
Permanent Eave Lighting
$799
100ft Govee permanent RGB outdoor lights + dedicated outlet, mounted & installed — never hang holiday lights again
GHome in-wall fan speed + light dimmer combo, supplied & installed to code
Fingerprint Door Lock Install
$299
GHome biometric smart lock — supplied & installed, codes & app set up for the family
Unique electrical tools & home essentials
Hard-to-find diagnostic tools and must-have electrical products — pro-grade gear I put to work in your home, or boxed up for you to keep.
Thermal Panel Inspection
$199
Pro thermal camera scan of your breaker panel — finds hot, failing breakers before they burn up
Circuit Mapping & Labeling
$149
Every breaker traced, mapped & labeled with a pro circuit finder — no more guessing at the panel
Homeowner's Safety Tool Kit
$129
Non-contact voltage tester + outlet tester — the same test gear I use, with a quick-start safety card
Smoke & CO Detector 3-Pack
$249
3 10-year sealed-battery detectors, supplied & installed, tested before I leave
Whole-Home Surge Protector
$399
Panel-mounted surge defense for the entire house, supplied & installed
GFCI Outlet 3-Pack
$299
3 GFCI outlets for kitchen, bath & outdoor — supplied & installed to code
Pro tools — buy the same gear I use
The exact tools I carry — Klein hand tools, Fluke & Amprobe test gear, FLIR thermal, Ideal benders. Genuine, new-in-box, yours to keep. Tool-only prices; professional install available on anything.
Klein 11063W Katapult Stripper
$42
Self-adjusting wire stripper/cutter, 8–22 AWG — tool only
Klein D213-9NE Lineman's Pliers
$56
9″ high-leverage lineman's pliers, New England nose — tool only
Klein 32500 11-in-1 Driver
$24
11-in-1 screwdriver/nut driver — replaces a whole pouch — tool only
Klein D203-8N Long-Nose Pliers
$46
8″ long-nose pliers with side cutter — tool only
Klein 1005 Crimper
$42
Insulated crimping/cutting tool — tool only
Klein 11045 Wire Stripper
$24
Everyday stripper/cutter, 10–18 AWG — tool only
Klein 11061 Self-Adjusting Stripper
$41
Auto-grips any gauge, no dial — tool only
Fluke 117 Multimeter
$308
True-RMS electrician's DMM with AutoVolt & LoZ — tool only
Fluke 325 Clamp Meter
$500
True-RMS 400A AC/DC clamp + temp/frequency — tool only
Fluke 1AC-A1 II VoltAlert
$59
Non-contact voltage tester, CAT IV 1000V — tool only
Fluke T+PRO Tester
$193
Voltage/continuity tester with GFCI trip test — tool only
Fluke 62 MAX+ IR Thermometer
$343
Dual-laser infrared thermometer, 12:1 spot ratio — tool only
Amprobe ST-102B Socket Tester
$39
6-function GFCI receptacle tester — tool only
Amprobe BT-250 Breaker Tracer
$305
Finds the right breaker on live circuits — tool only
Amprobe BT-250/KIT Combo
$252
Breaker tracer + GFCI tester in a hard case — tool only
FLIR ONE Edge Pro
$741
Wireless phone thermal camera — no connector hassle — tool only
FLIR TG267 Spot Camera
$577
Handheld thermal camera for job documentation — tool only
Ideal 74-001 Bender
$118
1/2″ EMT ductile iron bender, complete with handle — tool only
Ideal 74-002 Bender
$157
3/4″ EMT ductile iron bender, complete with handle — tool only